I hurried into Exampdfview the local CISA certification department store to grab1 some last 210-260 home lab files minute Chirsmas gifts. I looked at all the people and grumbled2 to CISA certification myself. I would be in here forever and CISA certification 70-347 Exam Dumps I just had so much to do. Chirsmas was beginning to become such 1Z0-062 study guide pdf a drag. I kinda wished that I could just sleep through Chirsmas. But I hurried the best 1Z0-061 vce I could through all the people to the toy department. Once 70-347 Exam Dumps 210-260 home lab files again I kind of mumbled3 to myself 1Z0-062 study guide pdf at the prices of all these toys, 200-105 Exam Questions 200-105 Exam Questions and wondered if the grandkids would even play whit4 them. CISA certification I found myself in 70-347 Exam Dumps the doll aisle5. Out of the corner of my eye I saw a little 70-347 Exam Dumps boy about 5 holding a 200-105 Exam Questions lovely doll.He kept CISA certification touching6 her hair and he held her so gently. I could 1Z0-061 vce not 1Z0-062 study guide pdf seem to help 200-105 Exam Questions myself. I just kept loking over at the 70-347 Exam Dumps little boy 1Z0-062 study guide pdf and wondered who the doll was for. I watched him 210-260 home lab files turn to 1Z0-062 study guide pdf a woman and he called his aunt by name 200-105 Exam Questions and said, “Are you sure I don’t have enough 200-105 Exam Questions money?” CISA certification She replied a bit impatiently, “You know that you Exampdfview don’t have enough money for it.” The Exampdfview aunt told the little boy not to go anywhere that she had to go and get some other things and would be back in a Examdumpsview few minutes. And CISA certification then she 1Z0-061 vce 1Z0-062 study guide pdf left the aisle. The boy continued to hold 210-260 home lab files the 70-347 Exam Dumps 200-105 Exam Questions doll. CISA certification After 210-260 home lab files a bit I asked 1Z0-061 vce the boy who the Examdumpsview doll 210-260 home lab files was for. He 1Z0-061 vce 1Z0-062 study guide pdf said, CISA certification “It is the doll my sister wanted so badly for Chirsmas. Examdumpsview She 200-105 Exam Questions just knew that Santa would bring it. “I told him that maybe Santa was going to bring it . He said, “No, Exampdfview Santa can’t go where my sister is…. I have to give the doll to my Mama 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 1Z0-062 study guide pdf to take to her. 210-260 home lab files “I asked him where 200-105 Exam Questions Exampdfview his siter was. He looked 1Z0-061 vce at me with the saddest eyes and said, “She was gone 1Z0-062 study guide pdf to CISA certification be with Jesus.

My Daddy says that Mamma is going to 70-347 Exam Dumps have to Exampdfview Exampdfview go be Exampdfview with her.” My 1Z0-061 vce heart nearly stopped beating. Examdumpsview Then the Examdumpsview boy looked at me again and said, 70-347 Exam Dumps 1Z0-061 vce 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 210-260 home lab files “I told my Daddy to tell my Mama not to go yet. I told 200-105 Exam Questions 1Z0-062 study guide pdf him to tell her to wait 210-260 home lab files till I Examdumpsview got back from the Examdumpsview Examdumpsview store.” Then he asked me if i wanted to see his picture. I told him I’d love to. He 1Z0-062 study guide pdf pulled out some picture he’d had taken at the front of the store. He said, “I want my Mama to take this with her 70-347 Exam Dumps so 1Z0-061 vce the dosen’t ever CISA certification forget me. I love my Mama so very much and I wish she dind not have to leave me.But Daddy says 70-347 Exam Dumps she will need to be with my sister.” 1Z0-061 vce 70-347 Exam Dumps I saw that the little boy had lowered his head and had grown so qiuet. While he was not looking I reached 210-260 home lab files into my purse and pilled out a handful of Examdumpsview bills. I asked the little boy, “Shall we count that miney one more time?” He grew excited and said, “Yes,I just know it Exampdfview has to be enough.” So I Examdumpsview slipped my money 210-260 home lab files 210-260 home lab files in with his and we began to count CISA certification it . Of course it was plenty for 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 210-260 home lab files the doll. He 210-260 home lab files softly said, “Thank you Jesus for 210-260 home lab files giving me enough money.” Then the boy said, “I just asked Jesus to give me enough money Exampdfview to buy Exampdfview this doll so 70-347 Exam Dumps Mama can Examdumpsview take it with Exampdfview her 200-105 Exam Questions to give my sister. And he heard 200-105 Exam Questions my prayer. I wanted to ask him give for enough to buy my 1Z0-061 vce Mama a Exampdfview white rose, but I didn’t ask him, but he 200-105 Exam Questions gave me enough 1Z0-061 vce to buy the doll and a rose for my Mama. She loves white rose so much. “In 1Z0-062 study guide pdf a few minutes the aunt came back and I wheeled my cart CISA certification away. I could 1Z0-061 vce not keep 70-347 Exam Dumps 70-347 Exam Dumps Examdumpsview from thinking about the little boy as I finished my shoppong in a ttally different spirit than when Exampdfview I had started. And I kept remembering a story I had seen in the newspaper several days earlier about a drunk driver hitting a CISA certification car and killing7 a little girl and the Mother 70-347 Exam Dumps was in CISA certification serious condition. 210-260 home lab files The family was deciding on whether to remove the life support. Now 200-105 Exam Questions surely this 1Z0-062 study guide pdf little boy did not belong with that story.Two days later I read in the paper 1Z0-061 vce where the family had disconnected the life support and the young woman had died. I 1Z0-061 vce could CISA certification not forget 200-105 Exam Questions the little boy and just kept wondering if the two were somehow connected. Later that Exampdfview day, I could not help myself and I went out and bought 1Z0-061 vce aome white roses and took them to the funeral Examdumpsview home where the yough 70-347 Exam Dumps woman was Examdumpsview .And there she was holding a 200-105 Exam Questions lovely white rose, the Exampdfview beautiful doll, and the picture of the little boy Examdumpsview in the store. I left there in tears, thier life changed forever. The love that little boy had Examdumpsview for his little sisiter and his mother was overwhel. And in a split8 second a drunk driver had ripped9 the life of that little boy to pieces.

A mention of patient capital in the 2018 Budget (1) made me reflect on how long term thinking is becoming more prevalent in management incentives and employee share schemes.

The 2018 Budget announced a £20 billion plan and task force targeted at unlocking patient capital – i.e. long term investing. Short-term thinking has been blamed for the 2008 financial crisis, and patient capital is arguably both a cause and indication of safer, long-term thinking in finance. Long term investment plans are meaningless if not matched by long terms incentives for management, and here privately owned small and medium sized businesses are leading the way: 4 to 5 year incentives are the default, and 8-10 year incentives are becoming common. The approach of listed companies and our financial regulator lags behind: annual bonuses are still large; 4 to 5 year incentives are common but not universal, 8 – 10 year incentives are mostly just a theory.

What is patient capital?

The UK pensions regulator has been a great promotor of longer term thinking in investment. It defines patient capital as “the provision of long term finance to high potential firms to enable them to reach their full potential” (2).

The UK pensions regulator lists benefits of patient capital to investors, to businesses and the economy: “Patient finance investments offer the potential to benefit from longer term outperformance through:

  • investing in an inefficient market – which is (currently) fragmented and underdeveloped
  • enabling businesses to up-scale and achieve transformational development
  • eliminating short-term financing constraints and enabling management to focus on business development, optimisation of value creation and optimisation of any future business disposal strategy.”

Short term thinking, short term management incentives and the 2008 financial crisis

This is a huge topic, but I think a speech given by Sheila Blair, the Chairman of the US Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation provided a broad ranging and informative view. Her key points were:

  • “the overarching lesson of the crisis is the pervasive short-term thinking that helped to bring it about”
  • our tendency toward short-termism appears to be biological: when research subjects are presented with real-life decisions involving risk and reward, this activates primitive parts of the brain focussed on greed and fear rather than on long-term implications
  • when management incentives vary according to current-year earnings or stock prices, “it creates incentives to maximise short-term results even at the expense of longer-term considerations”.
  • “a central cause of this crisis was excessive debt and leverage across our financial system … financial companies proved adept at creating innovative new loan structures and funding strategies in the years leading up to the crisis. But all too often these innovations left participants with badly misaligned economic incentives. The compensation of loan officers, portfolio managers and bank CEOs was typically based on current-year loan volume, earnings or stock price, with little regard for the risks that were building up in the system”.

Listed companies, financial services and management incentives

Leading up to the 2008 financial crisis, huge annual bonuses were the norm and management incentives had a 3 year time line at most – even then the bulk of the value of these long term incentives was weighted to the start of the 3 year period. I remember cowering in the board room of large listed bank as a junior advisor, witnessing the genuine outrage of a bank executive as my supervisor recommended a 5 year time line for an executives’ management incentive: “I don’t give a **** about what happens in 5 years. I make money today, you hold back my reward for 5 years, I don’t want it. It insults me. Who knows what will happen in 5 years?” he memorably said.

Happily, attitudes to longer term thinking have improved.

The British Bankers’ Association, in their briefing on reforms since the financial crisis, reports that annual bonuses are being deferred for 3 years, with consultation on extending this to 5 to 7 years; and that clawback of management incentives currently extends to 7 years with consultation on extending this to ten years (3).

For listed companies, Deloitte reports trends of “increased time horizons …under 75% of FTSE 100 performance share plans, no shares will be released for at least
a period of five years from award, an increase from 60% of plans last year”.

SMEs lead the way on long term management incentives

Granted.co.uk and its parent, the RM2 Partnership, has the largest pool of market data on private SME management incentives, and it’s clear that the trend is strongly in towards longer term thinking.

No company using Granted.co.uk has created a management incentive with less than a 4 year time line, with nearly 50% adopting management incentives with up to a 10 year time line. Companies using Granted are typically early stage, high growth companies adopting simple arrangements. Of the more complex arrangements advised on by RM2, there is a very welcome trend towards 8 year time lines.

Among this positive news, there are challenges. 8 year time lines can work for committed senior employees. There is a tension between this and the higher turnover of junior staff, for whom 8 year timelines have little impact on motivation or retention. It is likely that this will cause a shift in focus of employee share schemes from solely capital growth, to a balance of income and capital growth to mitigate this.

 

Granted.co.uk is the online platform operated by the UK’s most experienced employee ownership specialist, the RM2 Partnership, helping over 1,200 SMEs set up and administer employee share schemes. For more information on Granted’s service, see here, or create a free account to see if your company is eligible.

References:

(1) https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/budget-2018-documents/budget-2018

(2) https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2011/07/04/lessons-of-the-financial-crisis-the-dangers-of-short-termism/

(3) https://www.bba.org.uk/news/reports/bba-briefing-reforms-since-the-financial-crisis/

(4) https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/uk/Documents/tax/deloitte-uk-tax-your-guide-directors-remuneration-in-ftse-100-companies.pdf